August 12, 2019
Last year’s calculations by Chicago-based watchdog Truth in Accounting, which said total U.S. government spending was nearly double the official numbers, drew considerable attention.
Readers in the forensic accounting community, financial technicians, and physical gold investors quickly grasped the implications.
But the totals—USD $4.7 trillion in annual off-book government spending—were so massive, mainstream media and analysts kept mum. No longer.
Jeff Gundlach , president of DoubleLine Capital and whom CNBC refers to as the “Bond King”, tacitly backed that reasoning recently by pointing out that using “true accounting,” the U.S. government’s deficit is closer to USD $6 trillion.
That is nearly six times higher than private sector sources estimate.
Gundlach made the comments in DoubleLine’s July podcast, noting that the true U.S. deficit comprises a stunning 30% of GDP.
If Gundlach, whose firm manages USD $140 billion in assets, is correct, it means that to account for its deficits correctly, the U.S. government would also have to account for increases in unfunded liabilities on its financial statements each year.
This suggests that true U.S. government spending may be nearly double what the official numbers suggest.
Government accounting: less reliable than private sector data?
The idea that U.S. government data could be less accurate than much-maligned private sector accounting seems rich. After all, governments claim that their regulatory oversight is crucial to keeping businesses in line.
Sadly, when it comes to financial data, public sector officials appear to be less reliable than those in the corporate world.
That’s particularly true when it comes to recording expenses.
According to Sheila Weinberg, Truth in Accounting’s founder & CEO, the U.S. federal government accounts for its pension and medicare spending on a “cash” basis rather than the stricter Generally Accepted Accounting Standards that businesses use.
“We have fought for years to get the government to include Social Security and Medicare liabilities and related expenses on their financial statements,” says Weinberg. “But they insist on doing Enron style of accounting.”
U.S. Debt Clock and Truth in Accounting data, unfunded liabilities total approximately $120 trillion. That’s
more than six times the official U.S national debt and works out to roughly
$750,000 per taxpayer.
Chart courtesy of Truth in Accounting
(The U.S. Department of the Treasury’s press office did not respond to numerous requests for detailed information about its calculations, nor about why it uses accounting practices that would land any corporate CEO in jail).
What about other government data?
Gundlach’s comments provide support and vindication for Truth in Accounting as well as Boston University professor Laurence Kotlikoff and other accounting watchdogs who have been warning for years about the shifty government accounting.
However, they also raise new questions about the reliability of other U.S. government data.
For example, John Williams of ShadowStats, whom we have described as “America’s most important statistician”, has long claimed that the U.S. government has been manipulating GDP, unemployment, and inflation data for almost three decades by consistently changing the way it makes the calculations.
Modern econometrics may be useless
If Gundlach is correct, this would also have huge implications for the sophisticated econometric models used by university researchers, central banks, and financial institution forecasters.
These models rely on highly detailed and precise data, with GDP and government spending numbers calculated down to the decimal point.
However, massive “off the books” government spending, in the form of unaccrued pensions and other liability increases, dwarf the actual reported numbers, thus rendering economists’ ultimate calculations highly questionable.
This may explain in part why—as Larry Summers notes— major U.S. economics forecasters have never predicted a recession one year in advance.
Investment implications: “I am certainly long gold”
That said, even if investors believe comments by Gundlach, Williams, and Kotlikoff, it is unclear about how they should act.
That’s because governments, universities, and the big banks—who are heavily reliant on government protection—thus use the optimistic official data, almost without question.
This may have created what George Soros (of all people) calls “reflexivity”—a two-way feedback loop in which investor perceptions affect their environment, which in turn affects their perceptions.
More bluntly, sloppy government data during recent decades may have been making Americans feel better about themselves, leading them to spend more, and thus to make the economy seem better than it actually is.
“Bad accounting is hurting representative democracy,” says Weinberg. “It makes it impossible for both citizens and elected officials to act as knowledgeable participants in their government’s tax and spending policies.”
Investing in this kind of climate would appear to be a fool’s game. At minimum, individual investors will clearly need to educate themselves better and to ask harder questions to those who are advising them.
As for Gundlach: “I am certainly long gold,” jokes the Bond King. “If (governments) are going to confiscate your wealth, at least you can bury it in your back yard.”
Peter Diekmeyer is a business writer/editor with Sprott Money News, the National Post and Canadian Defence Review. He has studied in MBA, CA and Law programs and filed reports from more than two dozen countries.
The views and opinions expressed in this material are those of the author as of the publication date, are subject to change and may not necessarily reflect the opinions of Sprott Money Ltd. Sprott Money does not guarantee the accuracy, completeness, timeliness and reliability of the information or any results from its use.You may copy, link to or quote from the above for your use only, provided that proper attribution to the source and author is given and you do not modify the content. Click Here to read our Article Syndication Policy.
Bedankt voor je aanmelding.
Vanaf heden ontvang je dagelijks de meest opmerkelijke headlines van de dag.
Je kunt het venster nu sluiten.
Goudportal.nl is in 2009 opgericht door Richard de Feber om de andere kant van het economische nieuws te belichten. Veel van het nieuws omtrent de economie en de crisis dat wordt gepubliceerd door de gevestigde media is totaal niet gebaseerd op de huidige werkelijkheid. Mensen beginnen wakker te worden uit de droom dat de economie altijd maar door kan groeien. De gemiddelde burger wordt steeds slimmer en gaat zelf op onderzoek uit.
Goudportal.nl heeft een unieke samenstelling van nieuws voor u geselecteerd, zodat u altijd op de hoogte bent van wat er speelt in de wereld. Op Goudportal.nl staan dagelijks nieuwe headlines over de economie, goud, cryptocurrencies en nog tal van andere onderwerpen. U kunt zelf bepalen welke onderwerpen u als nieuws wenst te zien op Goudportal.nl. U kunt de rubrieken zelf in of uitschakelen en zo het nieuws te personaliseren.
Heeft u zelf interessant nieuws dat u wilt delen? Tip de redactie en stuur een e-mail naar [email protected].
Bedankt voor uw bericht. Wij gaan er zo snel mogelijk mee aan de slag! U kunt het venster nu sluiten.